Hero approached OCF to produce two music videos in August 2009. Lying In The Closet was chosen to be the first video to go into production in early August. The concept, developed by Adam Stephenson, was to homage the film Silence of The Lambs, and have a young FBI agent on the trail of a serial killer known as the Closet Killer. When she tracks him from Ottawa to Niagara, she discovers him hiding in a run-down house with a female victim, still alive in an upstairs closet.

The video was shot in one day in Port Robinson Ontario, with Dina Robert as the FBI Agent, Paige Gillespie as the young victim, and Mark Yuhasz as the Closet Killer.